(navigation image)
Home American Libraries | Canadian Libraries | Universal Library | Community Texts | Project Gutenberg | Children's Library | Biodiversity Heritage Library | Additional Collections
Search: Advanced Search
Anonymous User (login or join us)
Upload
See other formats

Full text of "Writings on Symbolic Interactionism by Tsukasa Kuwabara"



raa^U/tf^hu 



1 


"^. Repository 



























KV.DSIIIMA LIVFVRUS1TV 



Introduction to a Sociological Perspective of 
Symbolic Interactionism: Corrected Edition 



Tsukasa Kuwabara 
Maki Aburada 

Abstract 

The main purpose of this study is to examine the theory of Symbolic Interactionism formulated 
by Herbert Blumer, from the following viewpoints: 

a) How does Symbolic Interactionism explain the concept of socialization, i.e., the process 
in which hominids become human beings? 

b) How does Symbolic Interactionism explain the concept of Vergesellschaflung (Simmel, G.), 
i.e., the process or mechanism through which people construct human society? 

c) Why is human society to be considered to be a changeable process? 
After careful examination, the following findings were made: 

i) Blumer regards socialization as the process in which the two frameworks or perspectives 
(schemes of definition and generalized roles) that have been acquired by an actor through 
interactions with groups of others guide his/her interpretations/definitions. 

ii) In Blumer's theory, society is seen to be possible only when each of the actors in 
interactions can properly grasp the two standpoints (that of the other and one's own 
standpoint in the eyes of the other) by doing a kind of self-interaction (i.e., taking into 
account of taking into account; the concept taking into account of taking into account is 
the famous terminology used by N. Luhmann, but it was originally formulated by Blumer 
himself in 1953). 

iii) Because of the nature of others (black boxness), all the actors interacting with others are 

seen to be necessarily forced to revise their interpretations/definitions continually. For 

this reason, society must be regarded as a changeable process. 

Finally, we have tried to review critically the research method of Symbolic Interactionism (i.e., 

the approach from the standpoint of the actor) on the basis of the conception of man and society 

that has been clarified in the earlier chapters of this paper. Our review provides evidence for the 

two additional points listed below: 

iv) in doing the approach from the standpoint of the actor, only an individual can be included 
into the category of the acting unit. 

v) the standpoint of the actor perceived by researchers must never be seen as the standpoint 
in the raw but has to be seen as a kind of reconstruction of constructions created by 
researchers. 



m m ¥ n * si 76 -§■ 

We finally have confirmed that testing this conception of man and society (i, ii, and iii noted 
above) empirically, based on the points iv and v, would (and must) be one of our important tasks in 
future. 

In addition, this paper is the 'corrected' edition of the next article: Tsukasa Kuwabara, 2001, 
Introduction to a sociological perspective of Symbolic Interactionism (3)(The Summary of a doctoral 
dissertation, Tohoku University) KEIZAIGAKU-RONSHU~ OF KAGOSHIMA UNIVERSITY, 
54'. 

0. ^H<7)rVfS 

V>£>I#&, ->*3*- Jl'^tVXO- Mi^fSut^, ^-^-h ■ f)V--7- (Blumer, Herbert 
George, 1900-1987) <D V > ** V 7 7 fflSfMw (Symbolic Interactionism) if, T.s*— 7 >X£ t£ 
-L^-t*f»it»^±»±^^^, G.A.7 7 K^--^^^'btt^a^¥W*IE±« (S^±«) 
StfcfiJU ^tUcftfcafr^ffi^fifS&fMfcfr&gS** 7 fc Lfc£ fc (±JH< *nfetiTv>^ 2 

Wtt£J M«*S<HHi$fLT§fc t^h%, ft&fc, riWjAKJ (IS?* if) Ciot, ffM • 
ffigfifcSft* r«»»^®gj 4-v^L(i rSS&WJ l"£j£#SJii$J ii«tffii^, *3Lfctt& 
K^,S<IFfffi$tiT^^ 3 *IT' ft, ^-7-«y-/*'')7^M|«o, ^*f#a* 

-e ii , im & 4 US #> b , -?- o^ft Jfri«^» *i?-c fi , i/> j? 7 ? ffiiifMir £ * v> t 

1 http://web.archive.Org/web/20101112000357/http://ecowww.leh.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/staff/kuwabara/20100918/phdl9.pdf 

2 1960^{t-70^{tH7)^tTO, ^ r- -f A |£#- (1960^-75^), K;U ■ v 3 7 9 (-?V> ■ ya -;?), 7" 

vItL-C-&gILT^/:tt^¥«Olfy*L)f(±, -Ixi: l~*l*=£?fj fcDfHTJvt^Stf*, %<Dts:fr<D 1 o t Lreg 

-3'it (biix^z <ntf, •> * 3*'f-?)fta^ft6on 3 ir-ft tcfifit & 7 > --7- c i o -ciM $ a^ •> > *" u 7 * 

fflEffcffll&MS&^fcV' (fim 1981: 22-9)o 

4-i>l>7 h7 7it» Rfu±aj ttt#^cisit4 rtt^ffcii*j»A^igj ikx? mmm±%m\ Z, %<n 

mWit Lxm-fr±Xibiix^z, W*t*v>-cii, AWfclifl-W ■ l*iB<i*iJili{;J;oTSf)j6<j!c*4-fficofT 

n±^J **, Ttt^ftJ fc Ptt^MIJ fcv^ 2o«fj=ffl£AIS(:.SJrf;i:T~, AFHlIitt^iclg^6<j4-frSi 
/1^->*gi&fl«Jl;5CS XvifWlt^^f^t&Lk-biXX^&o U&it (1976: 3-4, 21, 24-5, 32, 34-5, 37-8; 
1983: 37-45) SO*' Wallace and Wolf (1980=1986) t#f,»;t„ 
4 http://web.archive.0rg/Veb/Vhttp://ecowww.leh.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/staff/kuwabara/doctor.htm 



1. mj<kHk&t(DM% 



19773 600 



1931=1969a: 169=1991: 220 



socialization 



society 



self-interaction 



interaction with oneself 



Cf. 2001:81-5; 2003a: 12 



p rocess of interpretation 



internalize 



indication 



interpretation 



socialization 



s ocializations 



roles 



chemes of definition 
generalized 
groups of others 



object 



perspective 



perception) 
conferring of meaning 

world of reality 



p hysical object 



social object 



abstract object 



world 



back 



talking 



action 
individual act 

fit, adjust 

impulse perception manipulation 

consumation 



2. ftKftmtLTOtiLi 



social interaction 

non-symbolic interaction 
symbolic interaction 

conversation of gestures 
use of significant symbols 



human society 
r eal form 
j oint action transaction 



significant symbol common definition 



taking into account of taking into account 



A. 
T. 2010: 

247 

Glascr and Strauss 1 964; 1965=1988; Scheff 
(1967a; 1970) 

2003c http://jairo.nii.ac.jp/0016/000051553 



\Atmmt(DMM 



w orld 



object 



4. fiJF$#£BF$#*#£0!)19ff 



standpoint of the actor 



society as symbolic interaction 



human society 



black box'ness 
2007: 6-7 N. Luhmann 1984=1993; 1995 

A. 
2008: 25-6 
Glascr and Strauss 1 964: 670-1 Soheff 1 967a 

Schcff 1 967b 



ensitizing concept 



naturalistic inquiry 



continuing interaction between guiding ideas and empirical observation 



empirical world 
resisting talking back negative 



r oot images) 



standpoint of the actor 



acting unit 



position of the actor 



acting unit 



reconstruction of constructions 



ttfB 

54 2001 



mm ■ tssi 

I : 

1977 
1 999 T OURh ttp://hdl.handle.net/10097/14389 

2009 N O.0501, 0601, 0701D iscussion Papers In Economics and Sociology No. 0902, 

The Economic Society of Kagoshima University h ttp://jairo.nii.ac.jp/0016/00004811 

2 010 

7 http: 

http://warp.da.ndl. go. jp/info:ndljp/pid/258347/w3. cc.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/on_doc/infomation/kouhou/no.16/kouki.pdf C f. 
http://warp.da.ndl.go.jp/search/archivesearch/WE00-ToWE05.do 

10 http://wcb.archivc.Org/web/20110121005951/http://ccowww.leh.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/staif/kuwabara/20100918/phd01.jpg 
http://web.archive.Org/web/20110121005951/http://ccowww.lch.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/stafl/kuwabara/20100918/phdl8.jpg 
C f. http://web.archive.Org/web/20110108030703/http://ecowww.leh.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/staff/kuwabara/memory.htm 

11 2001: 16 

2 001 2003a: 16 http://warp.da.ndl.go.Jp/info:ndljp/pid/258347/w3.cc.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/on_doc 

/infomation/kouhou/no.l6/kuwabara.pdf 1999=2007a: 

248-57 2001 

1 2005 ; 

2 2006b ; 

3 2006c http://hdl.handlc.net/10232/8982 ; 

4 2009 http://opac.ndl.go.jp/rccordid/000010122106/jpn 



a 1997: 68-70; 

b 2000c: 130-1; 

c 2001 : 77-86; 

d 2005 = 2006b =2007b=2009: 12-35 

http://wcb.archivc.Org/wcb/20110110013624/http://ccowww.lch.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/staif/kuwabara/20100918/DP 
no0902.pdf [Cf. http://warp.da.ndl.go.Jp/info:ndljp/pid/258347/ir.kagoshima-u.ac.jp/bitstrcam/10232/4197/l/D 
Pno0701.pdf 

[Cf. 2007; 

2 008: 60; 2010: 248] 2001 

2001: 69-77 

12 li 

2007 
[http://space.geocities.jp/isssn03890104no54/kuwabara-and-Yamaguch-2007.htmJtCf. http://sites. 
google, com/sitc/articlcsoftsukasak/ 1 5] 



//jairo.nii.ac.jp/0016/00005149 

2 008 

h ttp://jairo.nii.ac.jp/0016/00004809 

1 981 

1 922 



2 008 ) 69 

http://jairo.nii.ac.jp/0016/00004809 12 



http://hdl.handlc.net/10232/8117